CHAPTER
I - UNDERSTANDING FUTURES MARKETS
In today's agricultural environment, there is considerable risk in farming.
Probably the most significant risk to a farmer comes from large and rapid
commodity price changes. It is not unusual to see grain prices fluctuate
by as much as 10-20% within a year.
While this kind of price volatility can be a significant problem, it is
possible to be a successful marketer and take advantage of these kinds
of price moves. How can you successfully manage this risk? Probably the
best way is through forward pricing markets, which allow you to establish
a guaranteed forward price for your crops.
The
purpose of this text is to provide you with the necessary information
to use these markets in a successful and, hopefully, profitable manner.
It is important to recognize that forward pricing does not guarantee
the highest possible price for grain sold. At the same time, it is not
always imperative to forward price if market prices are not to your
liking. Therefore, our goal in this text is not only to help you understand
the mechanisms that you can use to establish forward prices, but also
give you the tools necessary for understanding when to make a pricing
decision.
This
reference guide has five major chapters. This chapter presents some
discussion of grain futures markets. It also discusses some of the issues
related to trading in the futures market including working with a commodity
futures broker. This chapter is intended for those who have a limited
understanding of futures markets.
Chapter
2 and 3 discuss how to use commodity futures markets to establish forward
prices for your commodities. Chapter 2 is devoted exclusively to using
futures markets while section 3 discusses using commodity options. Throughout,
a number of examples are used to illustrate how these methods work.
Chapter
4 and 5 present some of the basic tools of fundamental and technical
analysis. Fundamental analysis is the use of commodity supply and demand
data to make price projections. In chapter 4, we show some simple fundamental
analysis can be used to predict commodity prices and help you know when
to establish a price using a forward pricing contract. Chapter 5 discusses
some simple technical analysis techniques which are based on commodity
chart patterns.
A. Futures Markets: What Are They?
Futures markets offer an opportunity to establish a forward price for
your crop in advance of when it will be delivered to a local buyer.
This can include pricing wheat (or other crop) well in advance of when
you will actually produce it and sell it in your local market. While
a common misperception is that futures markets are nothing more than
gambling arenas, the truth is futures markets can be used to increase
profitability and lower risk.
In
a nutshell, futures markets are simply auction markets for forward contracts,
except in futures markets they are called futures contracts. We are
all familiar with forward contracts--a legal agreement between a buyer
and a seller to exchange a product at a later date and at a predetermined
price. In most cases, the "seller" of the forward contract
is the farmer while the "buyer" is a local grain elevator
or merchandiser.
A
futures contract is similar except that the size and delivery date of
a futures contract is standardized so that no one can change the contract
specifications. In fact, the only thing that is negotiated is the price.
The terms of the futures contract dictate what commodity will be exchanged
(e.g., corn), the amount of the commodity that will be exchanged (e.g.,
5,000 bushels) and the date when the exchange will occur, often called
the contract month (e.g., May).
The Futures Exchange
Futures
exchanges are government licensed markets for the trading of futures
contracts. There are numerous futures exchanges not only in the U.S.
but also around the world. For agriculture, the three primary futures
exchanges are the:
- ·Chicago
Board of Trade (CBT) where grain and oilseed futures contracts are
traded;
- ·Chicago
Mercantile Exchange (CME) which trades livestock and dairy products;
- ·Mid-American
Exchange of Chicago trades smaller sized contracts of agricultural
products.
The
exchanges provide space (called pits) where traders meet during a specified
time period to trade futures contracts. At the CBT, the grain and oilseed
contracts trade from 9:30 a.m. (Central Standard Time) to 1:20 p.m..
Individuals who trade contracts in the pits are exchange members and
may trade their own accounts or take orders from brokers or businesses
outside of the exchange.
Who Trades Futures Contracts?
People
who trade futures contracts are either speculators or hedgers. Hedgers,
who are also referred to as commercial users, protect their financial
position in the cash market by using futures contracts to protect against
adverse price moves. A grain elevator who signs a forward contract with
a local farmer will utilize futures contracts to remove the risk of
price changes. Farmers and other business that face a risk of loss from
adverse price moves can also use futures.
The
other group of traders is speculators who have no business interest
in the agricultural commodity. Their sole interest is to try and predict
price direction and profit from such forecasts. Some suspect that speculators
control the futures market by either making prices too high or too low.
However, because there are so many individualsboth hedgers and
speculatorstrading in futures markets, it is impossible for any
one person or group of individuals to control the price. While we may
not always like the prices offered on futures contracts, they are still
the best indication of what is a fair-value for the commodity in the
future. Granted, futures prices may and do often change dramatically,
but this is a consequence of new supply or demand information, which
changes the fundamental outlook. Being a good marketer will allow you
to profit from such changes through a forward pricing arrangement.
B. Trading Futures Contracts
Trading futures contracts is not a complex process and has many similarities
to trading stocks. However, some important differences exist between
trading stocks and trading futures contracts that are worth discussing.
Brokers
To trade in the futures market requires that you have an account with
a futures broker. Like stock brokers, futures brokers may provide trading
advice. Brokers will send you an account statement and will handle the
funds that you use to trade. For their services, brokers charge a commission
which varies, depending on the level of service, from $25-$75 per contract.
We will discuss brokers in more detail in a later section. For the moment,
just recognize that you will need to use a futures broker to trade in
the futures market.
Futures Contracts
Futures contracts are agreements between two parties. Like a forward
contract, there is a buyer of the commodity (sometimes called the ''long'')
and a seller of the commodity (a ''short''). You can sell futures contracts
without actually having pre-existing futures contracts. As a seller
or the short, you are agreeing to deliver the commodity in the delivery
month. The buyer or the long is agreeing to take delivery of your commodity
in the delivery month.
Now,
these obligations to make or accept delivery of a commodity sound quite
demanding but the benefit of futures contracts is that they can be canceled
or offset anytime prior to when the contract expires. To offset a futures
contract, you simply do the opposite of what your existing position
is. For example, if you have gone short (sold) a December corn futures
contract today, then you can simply offset it anytime between now and
December by buying December corn futures. This will offset your delivery
obligation. However, over that time, the December corn futures price
has likely changed. If the price has fallen and you buy it back at a
lower price, you will have a profit in your account. Conversely, if
you have to buy back at a higher price, you will have to pay the difference.
Margins and Mark-to-Market
Anytime you take a position in the futures market (either long or
short) you are required to post margin funds. Margin is a small sum
of money, which serves as good faith indicating that you will adhere
to the terms of the contract. Margins usually range from $500 to $1,500
per contract depending on the commodity and the market volatility at
the time.
Another
unique feature of futures contracts as compared to stocks is that profits
and losses are settled on a daily basis. On any given day, there are
winners and losers in the futures markets depending on their position
and the change in price from the previous day. Margin funds are used
to pay those who have profited from those who have lost. This adding
and subtracting from your account on each day is known as mark-to-market.
For
example, if prices increase, then those having a long futures position
will win and those having short positions will lose. The losers will
have money taken from their account to pay the winners. Therefore, one
of the main purposes of margin funds is to provide enough funds to assure
that you can meet these obligations if your account suffers a loss.
C. Grain Futures Markets
The largest futures exchange in the world for trading grain and oilseed
products is the Chicago Board of Trade (CBT). In fact, grain traders
in Chicago who wanted a standardized way to trade cash forward contracts
started the CBT in the mid-1800s.
The
CBT trades futures contracts for corn, wheat and soybeans (including
soymeal and soyoil). The contracts are for 5,000 bushels and have delivery
or contract months which differ depending on the commodity.
While
the CBT is the largest grain futures exchange, there are other grain
exchanges which may be useful. The Mid-American (or Mid-Am) exchange
trades grain contracts that are 1,000 bushels as opposed to the larger
5,000 bushels at the CBT. On any given day, there is little to know
difference in price between the two exchanges. Therefore, if 5,000 bushel
contracts are too large for your purposes, you may want to use the Mid-AM
market for 1,000 bushel contracts. In addition to the Mid-Am, there
is the Kansas City Board of Trade (KCBT) and the Minneapolis Grain Exchange
(MGE). These exchanges specialize in trading different grades of wheat
from the CBT's soft red winter wheat. At the KCBT, a hard red winter
wheat is traded while the MGE trades a hard red spring contract. Both
contracts are 5,000 bushels.
| Corn,
Soybean and Wheat Futures Markets |
| Exchange: |
Chicago
Board of Trade (CBT) |
|
Mid-American
Exchange (MidAM) |
| Contract
Size: |
5,000
bushels (CBT) |
|
1,000
bushels (Mid-AM) |
| Contract
Months: |
Mar.,
May, Jul., Sep., & Dec. (Corn & Wheat) |
|
Jan,
Mar, May, Jul, Aug, Sep, Nov (Soybeans) |
| Trading
Hours: |
9:30
a.m.-1:20 p.m. (CST) |
A
common misperception is that once you take a position in the futures
market you must accept delivery of the commodity (in the case of buyers)
or make delivery of the commodity (in the case of sellers). While
some individuals do exchange commodities when a contract expires,
the vast majority of traders exit their futures contract by offsetting
it prior to delivery.
For
example, suppose today you sold December Corn futures for a price of
$2.75 a bushel. This is referred to as going "short" corn.
Anytime between now and December, you can offset this contract by simply
buying back the December futures. This will offset your commitment in
the futures market. Of course, over that time period the price may have
moved lower or higher from the price you went short at of $2.75. If
you buy it back at a lower price, then you will earn a profit whereas
if you buy it back at a higher price, you will suffer a loss.
As
an example, suppose in November you decide to buy back your December
Corn futures contract and the price is $2.87 then you would suffer a
loss of $0.12 per bushel or $600 on one CBT corn contract. If instead
the price falls to $2.65 by November, the purchase of the December contract
would result in a profit of $0.10 per bushel or $500 per contract.
The
point in using futures contracts is to establish a price for your commodities.
We shall see later that by using a futures contract, you will establish
a forward price and regardless of whether prices increase or decrease,
you will still receive the contracted price.
D. Finding Futures Prices
In today's electronic age, it is rather simple to find futures price
information for little or no cost. Most newspapers that maintain a business
or financial section will provide futures price information and sometimes
option price information for the larger futures markets like the grains
and oilseeds. The most comprehensive national newspaper for this information
is probably the Wall Street Journal, although other financial oriented
papers carry similar information.
Probably
the most effective source of information on futures and options prices
is over the internet. The Chicago Board of Trade maintains an excellent
website with 10-minute delayed futures and options quotes. In addition
to the price information, there is a wide array of educational material
and market information for the products traded.
To
access the CBT website, go to http://www.cbot.com and you can access
the market price information from the menu.
If you have a futures account with a broker, you can usually access
futures price information from them via an automated telephone service
or also possibly through an internet home page.
E. Using a Futures Broker: Accounts and Margins
Because most individuals are not members of futures exchanges the vast
majority of the public must trade through a futures broker. A futures
broker is simply an individual that handles futures and options transactions
for his clients.
There
are basically two types of commodity futures brokers depending on the
type of service offered. A full-service broker provides trading advice
including market outlook information as well as guidance regarding futures
or options positions to place. This advice may come through phone calls
that will be made to you on a regular or semi-regular basis or via newsletters,
faxes or the internet. Sometimes, full-service brokers will call when
the market you are interested is moving quickly and they see a need
to place an order. While the commission will vary, the usual range is
about $50-$100 per round-turn trade (to buy and sell one futures contract).
The second type of futures broker is a discount broker. A discount broker
simply provides trade execution without market advice. Unlike a full-service
broker, a discount broker will not give you any personal opinions on
market direction or strategies but will only take your trading order
and handle your account. For this service, you usually pay around $20-$35
per round-turn trade.
Whether
you should go with a full-service or discount broker depends on your
comfort level with trading. If you have not traded futures or options
contracts, a full-service broker may be worth the extra costs because
they can provide more advice about strategies than a discount broker.
However, this does not necessarily guarantee that the advice that you
get from a full-service broker is the correct advice! An important aspect
to remember about full-service brokers is that they earn their commission
regardless of whether you make money on a trade or not. Therefore, they
have a strong incentive to have you make trades. This is true even if
the trades they suggest may not be the best for your needs.
If
you prefer to make your own decisions and not feel pressured by the
advice of your broker, a discount broker may be more appropriate. The
disadvantage of using a discount broker is that you must monitor the
markets on a regular basis and make your own trading decisions. However,
even some discount brokers offer market newsletters or other forms of
information which can help you make trading decisions.
Opening A Futures Account
Commodity brokerage firms generally require a client to deposit
at least $5,000 to open a commodity trading account. However, because
of the intense competition among commodity brokers, this amount can
be negotiated down and some brokers will not require any funds until
you are ready to trade.
To
open an account requires the prospective client to pass a ''suitability''
screening. This means that the prospective client be qualified for commodity
trading in the sense that he or she has been appraised of the inherent
risks, has sufficient financial resources to trade, and is not disqualified
by reason of mental illness or legal constraint.
Usually,
one finds that few mature persons who have financial resources beyond
the immediate security need of themselves and their families are turned
down as being unsuitable. Suitability does not mean that the prospective
client has demonstrated any indications of market or trading knowledge
likely to lead to profitable trading.
Most
brokerage firms now offer money market funds. Therefore, you can open
a commodity account and money market account at the same time. Funds
are transferred to the commodity account as required. As long as the
funds remain in the money market account the earn interest. Excess commodity
account funds may be moved to the money market account. This arrangement
has the advantage of allowing the trader to meet initial margin and
margin calls by simply transferring funds from the money market account
to the commodity account.
Types of Orders
To make futures or options transactions requires that you give certain
instructions to your broker. These instructions, also known as trading
orders, dictate how many contracts you want to buy or sell, the price
you are willing to accept on a trade, and the time period you wish the
trade to be executed.
The
most flexible order is a Market order. This transaction will be executed
''at-the-market'', meaning you will either buy or sell at the prevailing
price when the order gets to the trading pit on the exchange floor.
Using a market order is good when you want a trade to be executed immediately
as it will usually only take 5 minutes or less to have the trade executed
after you give your instructions to the broker. The downside of using
a market order is the price may be substantially different from the
price quoted when the order was placed. This is particularly true in
a volatile market situation where prices are moving sharply higher or
lower. Other market orders include Market-On Open and Market-On-Close
which are to be executed only during the formal opening or closing periods
for a trading day.
Of
time orders, the shortest lived is the Fill-Or-Kill (FOK) order. If
an FOK order cannot be filled when it arrives at the trading pit on
the exchange floor, it is canceled. A Day order is the next longer lived
order normally encountered. A day order expires at the end of the trading
day it is not filled before the end of the trading day. The longest
lived order is the Good-Till-Canceled (GTC) order which remains in effect
until it is either executed or canceled by the trader. While these orders
can be good to keep your order active if the market moves to a desirable
price level, it is important not to forget that the order is still in
effect. Many brokers will send weekly reminders if you have standing
open orders.
To
ensure that no more than a certain price is paid to establish a long
position, and no less for a short position, a Limit order is used. This
is typically stated as ''Buy 5,000 bushels of May Corn at $2.45 or better.''
The ''or better'' phrase allows the order to be filled at the limit
price of $2.45 yet does not prevent filling the order at a price more
favorable to the trader.
In
order to protect a profit, or limit a loss in the event that a trade
does not turn out as expected, a Stop-order, also referred to as a Stop-Loss
order, is used. A stop order becomes a market order (or limit order)
if the price falls to that level for a sale or rises to that level for
a purchase. A similar order is a Market-If-Touched (MIT) order. An MIT
order also is triggered if a certain price level is reached. However,
an MIT order is used to sell at a higher price or buy at a lower price,
whereas a stop order is just the reverse.
While
these are some of the more important trading orders, it is possible
to work out special orders with your broker. When opening an account,
ask your broker for a list of acceptable orders so that you may become
familiar with the terms and orders that they allow.
Margin Account
With every new futures trade, traders deposit money, called the
initial margin, with their broker. This margin serves as a security
deposit or performance bond guaranteeing that the trader will abide
by the contract terms. Traders must make this deposit whether they enter
the market from the long or short side. The initial margin is roughly
3 to 10 percent of the value of the contract although the amount can
vary by commodity and depending on how volatile the market price has
been of late.
It
is important to recognize that the amount of margin money is not the
most that can be lost from a futures trade. If you maintain a losing
position, you will be responsible for all losses on the contract, even
if these losses are more than the amount of initial margin. In fact,
your broker will require that you send more money (known as a margin
call) when your margin account falls below a pre-specified level, known
as the maintenance margin or variation margin. Your margin call would
have to be enough to get your account back to the initial margin level.
To
illustrate how margin accounts work, let's assume you take a short position
in the December corn futures contract at a price of $2.85. After calling
your broker to sell the December contract, you would deposit or have in
your account enough funds to cover the initial margin (plus commission).
Let's assume that the initial margin is $500 for a corn contract and the
maintenance margin is $300. Therefore, you would be required to post $500
to take the position and if your margin account ever falls below $300,
you would be required to send money to get it back to $500.
Example
Margin Account from A Short December Corn Contract
|
| Date |
December
Corn Price |
Profit/Loss |
Margin
Account
|
| 3/5 |
$2.85 |
|
$500 |
| 3/6 |
$2.83 |
+$100 |
$600
|
| 3/7 |
$2.92 |
-$450 |
$500
($350 margin call)
|
| 3/8 |
$2.91 |
+$50 |
$550 |
Because futures positions are marked-to-market, profits and losses are
paid-up on a daily basis. Profits are added to the margin account while
any losses are subtracted from the margin account. On 3/6, the price fell
to $2.83 so this resulted in a profit of $100 on one corn contract. This
$100 was added to the margin account balance to bring the account up to
$600. The following day, the price rose sharply to $2.92 resulting in
a $450 loss on the position. Notice that this is the loss in the position's
value from 3/6 to 3/7. At this stage, the margin account would have only
$150, which is below the maintenance margin level of $300. Therefore,
the trader would get a margin call by phone after the close of trading
to send $350 to bring the margin balance back to $500, the initial margin
level. For the last date on the table, the price fell 1 cent and $50 is
added to the margin account to bring the total to $550. Note that even
though the margin balance is $50 greater than the initial margin level
of $500, the trader has a loss of $300 on this trade because of the $350
margin call that had to be made.
As
you might suspect, if the market is quite volatile and moving against
your position, you may have several margin calls in a short time period.
If you get a margin call, you will be required to have the money wired
to your brokerage account and available before the opening of trading
on the following day. Thus, it is important to closely monitor your
positions on a daily basis so you can be prepared for such a circumstance.
Another possibility is to maintain additional funds in your account
beyond the initial margin, which your broker could use in the event
of significant losses to meet the margin requirements.
While
margin calls can create cash flow problems, as a hedger it is important
to remember that when you are losing money in the futures market, you
will eventually make it up on the cash market. For example, if you sell
a corn futures contract and the price increases, you will need funds
to cover the losses on the futures contract. However, when you go to
sell corn in your local cash market, your local price will be higher
and you will receive a higher price. The loss on the futures position
and the increase in the cash corn price will usually balance out. To
get around the cash flow problem, you should contact your creditor to
see if they will provide funds for margined futures trading. Many bankers
are happy to provide this because they realize that futures contracts
can help assure financial stability and profits.
|